Even so, the arguments are a little too rosy. It would have been more useful to have proponents of organic farming describe its limitations, and how these could be overcome. Lack of interest The film makes the point that traditional farming knowledge is not in wider use today only because the state has not shown any interest in funding research in this area. As Anil K Gupta, a professor from the Indian Institute of Management in Ahmedabad, says in the film, "The state has not been able to generate institutions and mechanisms, which add value to what people know." And commercial forces, which generate hybrid seeds and pesticides and market them, would have no interest in investing in increasing the applicability of organic farming.
The film also drives home the message that alternative farming, which in many cases rejects even tilling and weeding, also represents an alternative value system that stresses self-sufficiency rather than surpluses and profits. But, during the film's screening in the Capital, sceptics questioned the ability of such an approach to feed a vast and growing population. They suggested patronisingly that perhaps both "modern" and organic agriculture were needed in the present context, thereby implying that what is holistic and natural cannot be "modern".
In a note on himself, Bose explains his intention was to make "politically angry" films, which question the "basic development ideology and progress paradigms of